Monday, 28 April 2014

The Lunchbox (2013 - Dir: Ritesh Batra) reviewed



This is a delightful movie, not exactly a rom-com but romantic with a large dose of subtle realism.  I had missed it during the London Film Festival last October and only caught up when it went on general release earlier this month.  Set in the middle-class milieu of Mumbai where the eponymous lunchbox or the tiffin-dabba is an integral feature of daily life for thousands of the mega-city`s office workers, its simple story line centres around the virtual relationship between the two principal characters born of a chance mis-delivery of the lunchbox. 

As the film opens, we see Ila, a young married woman busily engaged in cooking a deliciously sizzling lunch for her husband (in fact all the later sequences involving preparation of meals are equally mouth-watering) and getting their pre-teen daughter ready for school, while at the same time conducting a loud off-line conversation with her older neighbour in the flat above through open windows.  Working to a fine time-line, she manages to see the daughter safely down to her school transport, a scooter rickshaw, and to put the lunchbox out for collection by the tiffin-carrier; only then can she sigh a breath of relief! 

Then follows live footage of the tiffin-delivery system at work, made familiar to audiences across the world by recent tv documentaries about this Mumbai phenomenon.  Next, the scene switches to a vast communal office layout, of the kind seen in American movies of the forties and fifties, where rows of clerks, seated at their desks, are seen engrossed in serious paperwork.  One of them is Saajan Fernandez, the recipient of Ila`s mis-sorted lunchbox.  We learn that he is single, a widower, nearing retirement after 35 years of service.  The lunch hall, separate from the work area, is where Fernandez eats his surprise, but welcome, packed lunch.

The crux of the plot is the two-way correspondence by handwritten notes tucked inside the tiffin box that ensues between Ila and Fernandez (we only have her first name, while he is referred to by his last throughout).  They exchange tit-bits about their past and present, the voids in their lives (she suspects her husband of having an affair, he is concerned about his future after retirement) and so it goes on, in the midst of other things happening around them. 

The filmic equivalent of pen-pal communications between two people who have never met is a familiar concept.  The letter writing dialogue of the 1987 movie 84 Charing Cross Road that develops into a real life post-WWII trans-Atlantic friendship between an American literary connoisseur and a British book seller, gave way to the internet shenanigans of Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks a decade later in You`ve Got Mail !  In Lunchbox, Ila and Fernandez fall back on the old conventional format but the effect is the same: they get drawn into a situation involving a sharing of confidences and mutual support, even to the extent of wanting to meet each other face to face.

Cinematic hype does overshadow the other characters, but a constant presence is that of an overly eager young recruit (Shaikh), whom Fernandez is having to train to take over from him when he retired.  After an initial lack of enthusiasm bordering on dislike, he warms to Shaikh`s importuning persistence and takes him under his wing.  Shaikh provides a certain light relief but also has a more central role than Ila`s husband and mother, both of whom remain on the periphery, as does Shaikh`s fiancĂ©e, who makes a brief appearance as a blushing bride in a marriage ceremony where Fernandez is persuaded to be Shaikh`s surrogate guardian. Ila`s upstairs neighbour with whom she has lively conversations however remains an off-screen voice presence throughout.

The urban metropolis of Mumbai - the vibrancy of the commuter train journeys, the street life, the apartment complexes, the taxi rides, the domestic scenes of family dining, the office culture – all that is well captured.  Nimrat Kaur as Ila is simply superb in terms of her dignified posture, resounding articulation and shining beauty.  Irrfan Khan, a seasoned actor (`The Namesake`, `The Darjeeling Limited`), lives up to his credentials to give an equally professional performance as Fernandez.   Nawazud Siddiqui who plays Shaikh too is not short of brilliance in his major supporting role.  He livens up an otherwise melancholic journey of his mentor towards an unpredictable denouement.  Ultimately, each character is a lonesome figure, who has to negotiate everything that life and living in the big city throws at them: Ila`s marriage has turned sterile just as her distant mother becomes a wailing widow; her daughter too is a singleton child of just one functioning parent; Fernandez has nothing to look forward to in retirement; only Shaikh - an orphan -  with a zest for adventure, represents hope and the future!   Above all, it is the food that leaves a lingering after taste.

On that note, The Lunchbox makes an appetising outing! 



RAMNIK SHAH
(c) 2014
Surrey, England 

Wednesday, 9 April 2014

Review of `Dancing With Destiny` by Urmila Jhaveri

                  
                                   `Dancing With Destiny : Memoir` by Urmila Jhaveri
                           ISBN 978-1-4828-1042-4 (Softcover); 978-1-4828-1043-1 (Ebook)
                                                       295pp  © 2014 Urmila Jhaveri
                                       (publisher: www.partridgepublishing.com/india)

  
This is more than just a `memoir`; it is an autobiographical account of an eventful journey through the author`s long life (she`s nearly 83) that dwells on the history of her country and people and draws the reader in with an endearing mix of candour and warmth, wit and wisdom, and much more.
 
Urmila Jhaveri is a second generation East African Asian, born in 1931 in Pemba, the twin island of Zanzibar where her Indian parents had migrated ten years previously when her father was recruited to the colonial customs service.  Some four years later, her father left his employment and the family moved to the mainland where he joined the business of a drug store that had been started a few years earlier by his older brother in Dar-es-Salaam.  This then was to be and remain her home for the next 75 years. It was here that she grew up, went to school, got married, raised two children and, while living a busy domestic and social life of a successful lawyer`s loving wife, developed her own independent persona of a veteran activist in the Tanzania national women`s movement Umoja Wa Wanawake Wa Tanzania (UWT).     
 
The narrative is not chronological in a linear sense; rather it meanders through a series of circuitously constructed themes (such as Migrations, World War II, Our Dhow Safari, A Brief Glance over Uganda in Part I alone).  She sets out her early trajectory in the first three chapters, aptly entitled Family Diary, Home and Happy Days.  In later chapters, we are given insights into the broader history of the region, the slave trade, the arrival of European explorers and the onset of colonial rule, interspersed with mature reflections on the lives of people around her.  What emerges is an unpretentious self-portrait of a modest woman with many hidden qualities and abilities.
 
We learn about her idyllic childhood, schooling and upbringing in a South Asian middle-class home, though as she says at the time she `never realised that it was an environment in which we were living in small racially bound compartments`, referring to the triple layered structure of colonial society where the Europeans occupied the top position, the native Africans were at the bottom and the Indians in between, and `(a)s if this was not enough, many other extra boundaries were self imposed and jealously guarded` (p 105), pointing to the complex class, caste and religion based community groupings among the Asians and other divisions in the rest of the population, though relations across these lines nevertheless remained cordial even if at times tensions did boil over. 
 
Beginning with an outline of her antecedents, parents` marriage and the birth of her siblings, she remembers her own first memory of `actual` India, as distinct from the vicarious India of imagination and folklore. This was in 1943, at the peak of World War II, when her family, like many others, had temporarily shifted there to elude a feared German invasion of East Africa.  As she puts it, until then “it never occurred to me that my roots were in India or [anywhere] else.  For us ... Dar-es-Salaam was our home .... for those of us who made our home in Africa, this sense of belonging was our bedrock on which we built our lives”.  As she adds, “for some reason I could not understand, I did not feel at home in Jamnagar” (p 78)!
 
Her description of the hazardous voyage across the Indian Ocean by dhow during the monsoon season, in wartime blackout conditions, reads like a hair-raising tale of adventure and survival.  It also gives an inkling of what the earlier, pioneering generation of migrants from India had had to endure, in their case for a better future but without any idea of what awaited them.
 
The Indian sojourn did not last long.  The family returned to Dar-es-Salaam when the war ended but during her time in India she had become betrothed to a  budding young lawyer, K L Jhaveri (whom she refers to as Jhaveriji and whose own memoirs were published in 1999 under the equally catchy title of `Marching with Nyerere`).  Although she had resumed her schooling in Jamnagar, she did not complete it to the Cambridge School Certificate standard after coming back to  Dar-es-Salaam. That however was not to be a handicap.  Her fate was to `dance with destiny` as it unfolded, through an amazing series of chance and opportunity, grounded in her cultural roots and on a solid marital foundation with a liberal ethos that enabled her to flower into a self-educated woman of great intellect and moral integrity.
 
Her husband`s high-profile legal and political activities gave her a unique opportunity to mingle with top national leaders and to learn about past and current affairs and what was shaping the country`s path towards independence. Part II of the book is devoted to these matters: `Pre-Independence`, `Travails and Triumph`, `Uhuru-Independence`, `Zanzibar Revolution`, `The Tanganyika Rifles Mutiny`, `The Birth pangs of a New Nation` and `Nationalization`.   But it is in Chapter 17, “Where are the Women?”, and a later chapter with an intriguingly long title “Camaraderie ... Djini Witches, Village Ancestors ...And mad men”, that we get a full measure of her involvement with the UWT.  She describes its origins and progress under the charismatic leadership of Bibi Titi Mohamed and how after an initial apprenticeship at district and regional levels, she was elevated to the Central Committee and became a valuable contributing member of that organisation.  Her account of the activities of the UWT - their meetings and travels across the length and breadth of the vast country, their encounters with varied people and situations and above all their endeavours to raise the lot of the downtrodden and marginalised women – is heart rending. She was the only Asian, the only non-African, among her colleagues, who all formed a close-knit bond of friendship and sisterhood. 
 
They campaigned and worked for an improvement in the status and education of rural women, dealing with sensitive cultural issues such as wife-beating and other forms of domestic violence, confinement to the home, polygamous households and child-rearing and lack of financial independence despite being “a labour force to work in the fields”.  Above all, it was the social oppression of the women, who were liable to be unilaterally divorced through the `talaq` process if they complained, that the UWT sought to address by “educating both men and women, and creating awareness about women`s rights”.  Their goal was “to push for women`s emancipation by initiating small-scale projects to enable women to earn, open kindergartens and nursery schools”.   
 
“Attending the meetings away from home meant for us late nights talking, joking, singing, sharing experiences and drinking beer and Fanta.  Many of our older members were Muslims who had formerly belonged to ngoma groups that were open to all, regardless of religious and tribal affiliation.  Occasionally there was mock posturing of visible tribal accents amongst the members like Wachaga and Wasukuma resulting in merriment all round.  Swahili was the common language that bound our understanding.  I had grown up speaking Swahili, and became fluent through using it continuously at UWT meetings and on long journeys to remote regions.  It helped me reach out, make friends, and find my own tiny little place in the lives of the village folks” (p 173).   In fact her command of Swahili was such that she regularly translated press reports and formal party documents into English for her husband!
 
In Part III, we learn about a couple of serious incidents of threat and assault in their later years, but on the positive side a great deal about her travels also.  In 1970 she was one of three UWT leaders chosen to represent Tanzania at the World Women`s Conferences in Moscow and Budapest.  It was a fabulous trip, which also included Leningrad and Moldavia, with a full programme of cultural and social functions and meetings with important people, among them the first woman cosmonaut Valentina Tereskova.  Elsewhere, she recalls her trips to Mauritius and Varanasi in India and “Tryst with a Tantric and visiting Kumbh Mela”.
 
In the closing chapters, she reflects on her spiritual journey through to the `evening of my life`, on her children and large extended family and basically everything that has happened to her, putting it all in a wider philosophical context.  There is a Waltonian (The Waltons – the 1970s American tv saga) quality about her homilies and other observations throughout the text.  So much is packed into the book – in terms of the countless number of people whom she remembers by name and of every significant turning point in her life – that for a reviewer it is an invidious task to highlight everything or to miss anything.  But what is clear is that hers is a life that has been lived to the fullest in every possible way.  Some of this can be gauged from the collection of old black and white photographs, among them of her with Julius Nyerere, his wife Maria Nyerere, Mrs Indira Gandhi and Dr Radhakrishna, in all of which she struck a charmingly beautiful figure who has aged well since.
 
What else?  Among her many vivid WWII recollections are seeing convoys of European PoWs and shabbily dressed, hungry and traumatised refugees (women, children and old men) being transported across to the station in Dar-es-Salaam, and how her father`s German friends came “stealthily to our house at night with their valuable books, artwork, paintings, delicate porcelain tea-sets and coffee-sets, for safekeeping or just to give away before they fled the country” (p 62).
 
And she remembers friends and neighbours and wider community contacts and acquaintances of all races and religions by name, often with details of what happened to them or where they ended up. 
 
There is more to the book than this selective and partial review can convey adequately. It leaves the reader with respect and goodwill for the author, for all her accomplishments certainly but above all for her strength of character, her humanity and her modesty and selfless service to the cause of women`s betterment in her native Tanzania.  Her husband, to whom the book is fondly dedicated, died just a few weeks before its publication. Of him, she writes in Acknowledgements, “without [his] silent support and encouragement I would not have written this book. Jhaveriji is always there for me; but he never tried to proffer advice or even commented on what I was writing .... letting me write our story in my own way”.   And with typical shyness, she adds:
 
“My book is based on facts drawn from history and my personal experiences, limited understanding and some impediments.  I am afraid there may be some unintended discrepancies, unseen gaps and even language shortfall and hope that, these may please be ignored (sic)”.  Undoubtedly these are present - and the book would certainly have benefited from some professional input and editing - but not so as to mar one`s enjoyment of what she has to offer.  For the academically inclined, it is also worth noting that as well as an appreciative Foreword by G Madaraka Nyerere, a distinguished Tanzanian journalist and commentator, the text is supported by a useful end section containing References and Notes. 
 
Having explained the genesis of her story in a moving Preface (how, having “arrived from familiar Dar-es-Salaam to Delhi”, she was feeling “like a bewildered, disconcerted, disoriented foreigner in India”), she concludes the book with a Postscript in a similar vein thus:
 
No doubt, all my experiences, relationships, actions and reactions have mo[u]lded my being.   And today, I am what I am, yet for me the enigma `Who am I?` remains ...
 
To complete the poetic summation that follows, that indeed encapsulates her, you must read the book.  It is an uplifting experience, not to be missed.

 
RAMNIK SHAH
© 2014
Surrey, England


 


 

 

   

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

Sunday, 26 January 2014

My review of 2013


For once, alas, I am late in posting this and the reason: we were away at the turn of the year, more about which later. The rationale for doing this every year was explained in my last review (for 2012).  It has remained the same and needs no elaboration or repeating here.  So as usual, I will begin with the books that I read during the year:

Books

1) The Taliban Cricket Club by Timeri N Murari – ISBN 978 1 74237 884 8 (p/b) Allan&Unwin – ©TNM 2012 – 325 pp – set in Kabul in 2000 at the height of the Taliban`s grip on the country – a fantastical tale of daring adventure involving an escape caper by a feisty female cricket lover.  Years ago I had read the accomplished Indian author`s `Taj`, an even more accomplished historical novel about the building of the great monument and so it was gratifying to see him in person at a literary event at the British Library in November of 2012 (see my listing of Talks & Lectures for that year).  I would however rate this book at 6 out of 10; enjoyable and informative but not a literary masterpiece!

2) The Accident by Linwood Barclay – ISBN 978-1-4091-3838-9 – an Orion p/b © LB 2011 – 386 pp – pulp fiction: started off well but at 2/3rd point became silly, tortuous, vacuous - (3/10).

3) Capital by John Lanchester – ISBN 978-0-571-23460-8 – faber & faber h/b © JL 2012 -  577 pp – motley collection of contemporary Londoners coping with the post-Lehman Bros financial crash … good characterization and plot but lacking real bite, though ending on a positive, if not exactly promising, ending - (7/10).

4) The Magic of Saida by M G Vassanji – ISBN 978-0-307-96150-1 – A Borzoi Book h/b © MGV 2012 – 304 pp – echoes of Paul Theroux`s `The Lower River`; a plausible tale of obsessive search for a lost past across time and space; a conscious attempt to synthesize the history of Muslim Indian migration, settlement and uprootment in East Africa into a personal narrative of both imagination and simplicity, with varying degrees of familiarity and exoticism (note: later in the year I was to attend the Vassanji Conference - see Talks & Lectures listing below - at which this particular book was the subject of learned papers and much follow-up discussion which enhanced my understanding and appreciation of the book) – (7/10).  
                                                                                        
5) The Honey Guide by Richard Crompton – ISBN 978 0 297 86795 1 – Nicolson/Weidenf h/b – © RC – abandoned as waste of time – police crime novel set in Nairobi in Dec/Jan 2007/08 – locational/cultural/political attraction did not justify reading this rubbish –(3/10).     

6) Undone by Michael Kimball – ISBN 0 7472 5535 0 – Headline Book p/b – © M K 1996 –  started well, with a promising crime thriller plot though with too much unnecessary detail – halfway through turned trashy – so another wasted and frustrating holiday leisure reading experience – am I losing it?  Not very happy about it – (3/10)

7) The Immortals by Amit Chaudhuri – ISBN 978-0-330-45581-7– Picador p/b – © AC 2009 -  set in Bombay of the 1980s/90s about a cultured Bengali upper middle-class family (by Indian standards) where the wife is keen to practise her musical talent and so performance music plays a pivotal role in the narrative – in structure the novel wanders and veers elliptically but the portrait of the main characters – the music teacher Shyamlal, the wife Mallika Sengupta and her son Nirmalya - is done with sensitivity and depth – and throughout of course Mumbai remains a compelling presence in all its familiar detail – of places, streets, hotels, suburbs and lifestyle of the better off  - but there is just too much detail – the language is paradoxically both direct and nuanced -  on the whole good  – (7/10).   

8) The King of Torts by John Grisham – ISBN 0 7126 7054 8 – Century p/b – © Belfry 2003- 372 pp - holiday read – usual annoying macho/cheeky/superficial style that turned the central legal eagle into an anti-hero whom one wished to see lose – here the guy, Clay Carter, is picked by a mysterious benefactor to elevate himself into a hotshot mass tort litigator – hence the title – and to screw the big corporations for product failures only to be faced on a potentially ruinous turnaround by his own clients fouling up class action settlements to their individual disadvantage but the author while tantalizingly whetting the reader`s appetite to see Carter go down with a bitter taste of his own medicine in the end lets him off on an inconclusive note – all rather disappointing – have gone off J Grisham and do not propose to read any more of his trashy airport/travel fillers – (2/10).

9) A Delicate Truth by John Le Carre` - ISBN 978-0-680-92279-6 – Viking p/b – © David Cornwell 2013 – 310 pp – brilliant, if at times trying because of long dialogues with too much detail and other asymmetrical bits of information and retrospective twists and turns of the story line – however the basic thrust of the narrative is clear: a select collection of spooks go on a top level sensitive mission to take out a bunch of suspected al-Q types in Gibraltar (reminiscent of that real-life IRA related incident of 1980s) … it turns out to be flawed – a fiasco – with sickening casualties – and they or one or two of them are so morally outraged to want to `out` the secret to the outside world and so Le Carre` keeps us on tenterhooks as he navigates the plot with an insider`s perspective into the working of the spy networks, the bureaucracy of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office and the intelligence agencies – all very contemporary and topical – a good read indeed –  (8/10).

10) Shakespeare by Bill Bryson – ISBN 13 978-0-00-719790-3 – Atlas p/b - © B Brys 2007 -  195 pp – a delightfully readable account of the old Bard`s life and literature against the background of his time and journey through life –(8/10),

11) The Invisible Ones by Stef Penney - ISBN 978 0 85738 294 8 – Quercus p/b © SP 2011 – 526 pp – an intriguing tale on a subject scarcely touched on or explored: `the invisibles` of the title are the travelling people of the British Isles.  As she herself says in an Afterword, it is about the `in-between` world of such people, steeped in Romany Gypsy culture, as they interact with the indigenous gorjios through the generations, fictionalised in this instance with a detective`s investigation into the mystery surrounding a disappearance or suspected death of a young woman that uncovers a miasmic mix of incest, genetic disorders, close-knit communal dynamics and other complexities of relationships and characters.  This is a work of extraordinary imagination and depth.  Although not directly relevant, some of the `outsider/insider` parallels of the story would resonate with diasporic or minority ethnic folk in present day Britain  – .(8/10),

12) Long Lost by Harlan Coben – ISBN 978-1-4091-0219-9 – onionbooks.co.uk p/b – © HC2009 – a very poor Berlin holiday read – his style has deteriorated into a John Grisham-like macho brashness – too much trivial detail and unnecessarily complex plot – in the latter half we get a glimpse of the obsessive post 9/11 security apparatus that is driving western governments into an ever more oppressive regime of surveillance and counter-terrorist activity – (3/10)

13) The Last Train to Zona Verde: Overland from Cape Town to Angola by Paul Theroux - ISBN 978-0-241-14367-4 – © PT 2013 – Hamish Hamilton h/b – 353 pp – his latest and probably last travel book about Africa, a damning indictment – an African lament – full of despair and disenchantment – “What Am I Doing Here” the constant refrain – deserves a full review – (NOTE: as it happens, I have done a separate review of it on this blog – scroll down) - (9/10). 

14) Macaulay: Britain`s Liberal Imperialist` by Zareer Masani - ISBN 9781847922717 – 272 pp  © ZM 2013 - The Bodley Head h/b – a fascinating critical biography of the 19th century British imperialist by an eminent Indian (or Indo-British) historian nurtured in his legacy to the Raj – we are treated to the full measure of Macaulay`s character, personality, accomplishments and above all his lasting influence on India`s emergence as a unified nation enriched by British rule – (9/10).

15) Out by Natsuo Kirino (translated from the Japanese by Stephen Snyder)  - Vintage Books p/b -  ISBN 9780099472285 – © NK 1997 + Eng trans © Kodansha Int Ltd 2003 – 520 pp – a disturbing tale of violence and sex of the most gory kind that one sees in some of those explicit Japanese films; also we get a huge insight into the modern urban blight of lower middle-class life involving debt, vigilante justice and moral ambiguity; the mundane minutiae of modern Japanese urban life is graphically described – (5/10).  

16) Cave in the Snow: A Western Woman`s Quest for Enlightenment by Vicki Mackenzie – ISBN 0 7475 4389 5 – © V M 1998 - Bloomsbury p/b – 210 pp – inspiring true story of (Jetsumna) Tenzin Palmo – gives an understanding of the devotion to the Buddhist faith whether one agrees with its doctrine or philosophy - (7/10).

17) Gandhi before India by Ramachandra Guha – ISBN 978-1-846-14266-6 (h/b) @ R G 2013 – Allen Lane (Penguin Group) – 672 pp – a simply superb portrayal of the Mahatma`s life and making in South Africa before he returned to India in 1914 – a brilliant biography, by any standards, in terms of research, comprehension and writing – this was the best book that I read in 2013 and by an extraordinary coincidence I actually finished it on the last day of the year, while on a cruise somewhere off the coast of Cambodia! Hoping to do a proper review of it in the coming year - (10/10).

As usual an eclectic collection, but varied enough for me.  Of these, I would rank Gandhi before India as the best and most satisfying, closely followed by The Train to Zona Verde, with Macaulay and The Magic of Saida in the third and fourth places. 

Films, Plays, Concerts etc

Sun 06 Jan – Life of Pi – a hugely enjoyable experience; it brought vividly alive on screen, an incredible achievement in itself, the thrill and excitement I had felt while reading the book by Yaan Martel some years ago; when the movie was made I had wondered how it was going to be translated on to the screen but it worked; the computer animated action sequences added an extraordinary sense of verisimilitude = 8/10

Sun 13 Jan - Les Miserables – also an enjoyable musical – the period setting and the songs worked = 8/10

Sun 03 Feb – Lincoln – and yet another great movie – a hat-trick in an equal number of weeks!  It was evident that both the movie and the principal actor who played the lead role, Daniel Day-Lewis, were going to win some major awards; well Day-Lewis did win the Oscar for best actor = 9/10

Tue 19 Feb – Great Expectations – and a fourth great movie in succession! Echoes of school days = 8/10

Sun 03 Mar – Arbitrage - Rich`d Geer/Susan Sarandon – corrupt rich white billionaire involved in financial fraud on a massive scale, kills his mistress in a road crash of his own making and basically gets away with it; moral ambiguity prevails over a weak plotline = 4/10 

Wed 20 Mar – Gielgud Theatre, West End – The Audience – Helen Mirren as the Queen in one-to-one with a succession of her prime ministers; majestic in every way; theatre at its best = 10/10 

Sun 19 May – Mud – (dir: Jeff Nicholls) a large dose of Mississipi mud-pie – a touch of `Great Expectations` in the early scenes when the two boys come upon the fugitive whom they are more or less forced to help to evade the law = 07/10

Thu 30 May – RFH – Philharmonia Orchestra – (cond: E-P Salonen) – Stravinsky`s Rite of Spring Centenary – one of my favourite pieces of music – superb performance = 8/10

Thu 04 July – ICA - Night of Silence = Lal Gece (Turkish, Eng subtitles: Dir   Reis Celik) a really most magnificent movie!  It was absolutely riveting – intense, measured, beautifully acted.  Apart from the opening sequences that set the scene – of wedding rituals and social customs (not unlike traditional Indian), the rural setting and the wintry landscape – the rest of the `action` takes place in the bridal chamber where the couple (the man,considerably older than the girl) get to know and interact with each other - the marriage having been arranged to settle an old family feud in a `Zorba the Greek` mode – with an open ending, as it were (note: this was one of the 18th London Turkish Film Festival offerings) =  9/10

Fri 19 July – ICA – Pune 52 - (Marathi, English sub-titles) part of this year`s London Indian Film Festival - rubbish, rambling, unconvincing cheap thriller – a time-waster - should have walked out earlier than I did = 2/10 

Thu 22 Aug – ICA - Kuma (Turkish, Eng subtitles – Dir: Umut Dag) - Ayse, a 19-year-old girl from the Turkish countryside, is chosen to be married to the handsome Hasan, son of formidable and house-proud mother Fatma, who resides in Vienna with her husband and six children. However, what soon becomes apparent is that Ayse is to be second wife to Fatma more »'s husband. Intensely gripping social reality drama: close-knit family and first and second generation migrant cultural dynamics predominate, Ayse is warmly embraced by Fatima but at first resented by some of Hasan`s sisters.  Hasan the nominal legal husband turns out to be gay.  The paterfamilias dies and all sorts of complications arise – one felt claustrophobic at times – there is too much detail and introspection – the end comes as a release  (note: it is only after seeing the film that a google search revealed that `Kuma` in Turkish means a fellow wife (in a polygamous household or a concubine – if only I had researched this before, something that I failed to do because of other pressures – it would have made getting into the plot that much easier!) = 8/10

Sun 25 Aug – NFT1 – The Big City (Mahanagar) (Indian: Eng subtitles) Dir: Satyajit Ray - absolutely brilliant, set in the Calcutta of the early 1950s, a middle-class family`s struggles to come to terms with changed circumstances; above all a magnificent portrayal of the wife`s flowering as a working woman to supplement her husband and the sole breadwinner`s inadequate income as a bank executive in their traditional society where (and when, in period terms) that was almost unthinkable = 9/10   

Wed 18 Sep – ICA – The Stuart Hall Project – a docu-biopic of the veteran iconoclast / philosopher by John Akomfrah of the Little White Lies fame – the ICA blurb describes the 82 year-old Jamaican born British academic as “Venerated … for his knowledge of subjects as diverse as Miles Davis, Marxist methodology, the European Union, and American hippies … [and] regarded as one of the most inspiring voices of the post-war Left”. The focus of the film is his immense intellect as we are treated to his views on identity, culture, history and Britishness as he has seen it develop during his life-time (he is the same age as his Caribbean counterpart VS Naipaul, though with vastly different political and cultural leanings).  Unfortunately, I found Akromfrah`s much hyped production rather asymmetrical and lacking in direction and narrative cohesion = 5/10

Sun 22 Sep – Purcell Room – Darbar Festival Rudra Veena to Magnificent Khayal concert – magnificent 2nd part, Pandit Raghunandan Panshikar`s playing the Jaipur Atruli Gharana Khayal = 7/10 

Sun 29 Sep – Blue Jasmine (Dir: Woody Allen: Cate Blanchett, Alec Baldwin) – great movie, a vintage Allenesque portrayal of Blanchett as a rich, upper crust New Yorker married to Baldwin as the Madoff like fraudster who loses everything when he is found out and kills himself in prison leaving her penniless and who then flies over to San Francisco to scrounge with her low-life adopted sister where she behaves like Blanche Dubois in `A Streetcar Named Desire` - superb characterisation, gripping narrative with flashbacks and familiar location shots = 8/10                 

Wed 09 Oct – Purcell Room – Dayanita Singh & Talvin Singh – a conversation – 4/10     

Thu 10 Oct – NFT1 - As I Lay Dying – part of the London Film Festival (LFF) – Dir: James Franco`s taut, moving, focused adaptation of William Faulkner`s 1930 novel of a close-knit Southern family`s journey across the US to bury the mother of the household, with a superb atmospheric touch – there is a Steinbeck`s Grapes of Wrath quality about the place and period; once the viewer`s initial claustrophobic reluctance to get involved is overcome, the narrative becomes a rite of passage for the audience as well as for the characters = 8/10    

Thu 17 Oct – Curzon Chelsea - The Past – also an LFF offering – Dir: Asghar Farhadi (who had also made the award-winning A Separation some 2 years ago – see my Review of 2011 - an intense social psycho-drama from the perspective of Ahmad, an Iranian husband of Marie, the central female lead, who comes to Paris after a four year separation to finalise their divorce but is immediately drawn into her dysfunctional and emotionally draining relationships with her teenage daughter and her new lover and his rebellious young son with many strands to their interactions and daily lives – the acting is superb throughout, in particular that of Marie`s lover`s 10/12 year old son - the script moves the narrative along relentlessly; the whole experience is gripping = 8/10 (see also my separate full review on this blog, the preceding item)

Sun 17 Nov – Philomena (Judy Dench; Steve Coogan) a moving story of the search by an Irish-Catholic mother, now in late middle-age, of her son born out of wedlock in an era when that was completely verboten and so had to be given away for adoption =  8/10

Sun 24 Nov – The Butler (Forest Whitaker; Oprah Winfrey) a disappointing performance by Oprah, while Whitaker is absolutely professional in his rendering of the eponymous title, with fleeting cameo roles by big name actors playing some of the Presidents, generally over-rated (I was attracted to the movie because as a teenager I had come across the character of the President`s butler in Upton Sinclair`s Lanny Budd novels) = 5/10

Looking back, on the whole, a lovely collection.  I thought the two Turkish films and the Satyajit Ray move, but above all the Iranian `The Past` were the best, while of the Hollywood or American movies, Woody Allen`s `Blue Jasmine` ranking equal or nearly so.  


Lectures, Talks, Events etc

Wed 30 Jan – RSA – “The Runnymede Debate: Do racists have a right to be heard”? (Ch: Rob Berkeley – Panel: Catherine Fieschi, Kirsty Hughes, Sunder Katwala & Nigel Warburton) = 6/10

Thu 28 Feb -  RSA – “Liberty and Security – for all or the (privileged) few?” Prof Conor Gearty (Ch: David Aaronovitch) = 6/10   

Sun 10 Mar – QEH – “Alice Walker + Pratibha Parmar” (ch: Mariella Fostrop) great = 7/10

Thu 14 Mar – RSA – David Cannadine: “Common Humanity: Making `us vs. them` history” = 8/10

Wed 24 Apr – Drapers Hall – Chartered Institute of Taxation Awards Presentation Ceremony (self presented with a veteran`s certificate) = 7/10

Thu 25 Apr – QM London University - GLOCUL Talk by Maritsa Poros: Networks, Narratives etc (ch: P Shah) = 9/10

Mon 20 May – QEH: 2013 Man Booker International Prize Readings = 8/10 

Tue 4 June – Kings Place: Guardian Lectures - Paul Theroux = 8/10 

Tue 09 July – RIBA – The Spectator Panel on Immigration: David Goodhart, Ken Livingstone, Mehdi Hasan, Trevor Phillips, Peter Hitchens (ch: Andrew Neil) = 6/10 

Thu 12 Sep – RSA -`Syria`s Crisis and the Global Response` (Prof Michael Clarke, RUSI; Alison Bailey, Oxford Analytica; Dr Patricia Lewis, Chatham House; Ch: M Taylor) = 7/10

Thu 26 Sep – Purcell Room – Jhumpa Lahiri (ch: Bidisha) could have been better = 7/10

Sun 13 Oct – QEH - `The Man Booker Prize Readings` (ch: Mark Lawson – panel: Jim Crace,Jhump Lahiri, Elenor Catton, Coln Toibin, NoViolet Bulawayo, Ruth Ozeki) = 8/10

Thu 24 Oct – RSA 1-2 pm - `Does the British Establishment still exist?` - Peter Hennessy (ch: Andrew Rawnsley of The Observer) = 8/10

Fri 08 Nov – SOAS – M G Vassanji`s keynote address:`Assimilation – The Dream and Reality: The Case of the Asian African` (ch: Itesh Sachdev) = 7/10

Sat 09 Nov – SOAS: The International Imaginaries of M G Vassnji – Conference + Conference Dinner = 7/10

Mon 11 Nov – LSE – Ramachandra Guha on `Gandhi before India` (ch: Dr M Cox) (absolutely riveting …a brilliant exponent of his art) = 10/10 


Needless to say that the one that stands out prominently is Ramachandra Guha, with Theroux, Vassanji, Jhumpa Lahiri and Maritsa Poros following closely behind.  This year though there were relatively fewer such events, and this trend will probably continue from now on for practical and other reasons.      

Foreign Travel

We did three trips this year: to Turkey in June, to Berlin in August and the most recent, a three week + long out in the Far East over the Xmas and New Year period that included a 16 night cruise from Hong Kong to Singapore on the Holland-America MS Volendam.  All of them turned out to be enjoyable and hugely satisfying.  In Turkey we travelled across from Istanbul round the western Mediterranean coast through historical and tourist attractions such as Canakkale, Kusadasi, Pamukkale, Konya, Cappadocia and Ankara. Berlin of course has a lot to offer and lived up to our expectations and much more. Hong Kong is one of the most exciting and thriving cities in the world, while Singapore is unique: a paradise of an absolutely charming, elegant and beautiful city-state the like of which is hard to find anywhere else.  And our cruise liner touched at many ports along the coast of Vietnam (Halong Bay etc), Cambodia and Thailand – a lot of which was familiar to us as we had visited those places in 2001/02; but here too the progress that has been made since then is remarkable and was quite noticeable.    


General    

All in all, not a bad year, considering everything.   Going through the list in retrospect, it is always a matter of wonder that some of the early events happened barely a year ago and yet they seem so far back in memory.  I am rushing to complete this because it is overdue already, but what awaits?  Who knows?  For the time being, I will continue to fill my time as before!  Best wishes to everyone for the New Year.

RAMNIK SHAH
© 2014
Surrey, England